Originally posted by: TerranForces
Do you have any scientific proof that you can digest more than 45g of protein per sitting? All that link says is that "scientists" BELIEVE that you can digest more. Real concrete evidence there. Of course they will say that, so you eat more of their protein; and therefore, buy more of it too. Don't be so naive.
BTW, nobody is impressed that you can copy down the ingredients to VP-2 and falsely state that ON whey has 50% concentration. A test showed that it had 92% concentration and 13g of BCAA's per serving. You don't need a rocket scientists to figure this one out:
5lb On Whey 92% concentration for $25.
2lb VP-2 isolate (95-98%) for $36
Who knows if their claims hold up anyway. There is a reason On Whey is the #1 sold supplement by far. VP-2 doesn't even crack the top 50. I won't even comment on the car statement to spare you some respect.
36mg of iron is way too much for a multivitamin. Vit-min 75+, Now Adam, and Winfuel Men's have no iron at all. First of all, only women and blood donors need high amounts of iron. Not only is it slightly catabolic, but it will also interfere with the absorbtion of much more important minerals like Zinc. Most men have too much iron because of their diets anyway. Bran Flakes alone have 11g of iron per serving.
Symptoms of overdosing on iron have been shown at as low as 30mg a day. You definately don't want to push the envelope for something with such limited benefits. Once again, there is a reason why women's vitamins have iron and men's don't.
Do us all a favor, and stop spreading myths yourself. Creatine Ethyl Ester has been proven to have almost 3 times the absorbition of monohydrate, sesamin is a very popular and effective fat loss agent, and On Whey certainly does not have a 50% concentration. Get your scientific references from some place reputable like WebMd at least. I am beginning to wonder if you are a paid representative from AST.
Funny that you want to argue over something I've been doing for 16 years (yes, I've been lifting since you were born) and something you just started. Keep cut and pasting your bodybuilding.com info and myths that you've heard at the gym. My opinions are backed by results from personally testing any product that comes out of my mouth, as well as years of experience.
First off, link all of your studies, including the ON one. I can't trust anything you say so you need to provide hard evidence (just cut and paste the link you found from Google today). Second, I never said anything at all about ON Whey except that I got better results with VP-2. The ingredient list referenced your generic 100% WHEY POWER that you have linked for all the beginners to buy, look again it's in your first post. You know, the one with the Whey concentrate blend made by "High Power"? Reading is a necessity in life.
Of course VP-2 isn't a best seller, it's 2-3X the price of regular whey. Who can afford that unless you're making some good money. I tried it for awhile and got insane results, using it in strict bracketing meals. My results were better than with any other Whey powder for bulking.
You say:
"36mg of iron is way too much for a multivitamin".
Again, take the tinfoil hat off. Do you know how much iron a steak has? Are you going to stop eating red meat b/c you're worried about breaking the 30mg "limit" you set for yourself? Spare us please. Second, you never addressed the fact that bodybuilding.com said:
"However, for hard training athletes the PDI (performance daily intake) for men and women is from 25 to 60 milligrams." It's right out of your own Health Bible. I bet you follow all the RDA's to a T! Guess what bud, if you're even remotely serious about powerlifting then throw that sht out the window. You have different needs, that 10mg Iron RDA for a normal person does not apply to you.
I never took a single multivitamin while powerlifting and gained over 30 lbs of lean muscle mass with a benchpress that doubled my weight. Multi's are
not essential as long as you're eating fruits/veggies, it's the protein that's essential. Also, you don't have to buy the 100% pure isolate in order to progress, but that will give you faster gains. Nobody said Whey concentrate blends don't work, but its absorption rate is not as efficient as the high end powders and that is directly reflected by price.
Your 40-45g protein intake at one sitting is unsubstantiated. It's a myth, ask any World Class bodybuilder like Ken Cutler or Ronnie Coleman if they worry about how much protein they take in a meal. You would be laughed out of the gym!
Creatine Ethyl Ester: Keep hyping this product, and I'll keep taking my creatine monohydrate which is backed by over a decade of results. Yours is backed by nothing but hype and no study has ever proven this stuff to work. Period. I'm not wasting my money on sht that doesn't have a proven track record, maybe you feel comfortable doing so - more power to ya.
Any more info and I'll have to start charging by the hour (certified trainer). :laugh: