Originally posted by: dullard
Recycling PROPERLY is better for the planet. An easy way to tell is that recycling PROPERLY is better for your pocketbook. If you can get paid for an item, then recycle it. If not, then don't recycle it as at the moment it isn't good for the planet. It may be good for the planet later when we have the proper technology, but at the moment leave it be. It is such a simple concept, yet few people ever understand it. Instead, they tend to fall into two groups: people who never recycle (bad for the earth and their pocketbook) and people who try to recycle everything (bad for the earth and their pocketbook). So few people understand that the opimum lies in between the extremes and that it is a moving optimum as technology and needs change.Originally posted by: Crono
It's debatable depending on circumstances. In some cases, it costs too much in terms of resources to recycle products rather than to produce new ones.
The other two "R's" (Reducing and Reusing) are better options that aren't as questionable in terms of environmental benefit.
Note: economical recycling goes far beyond the easy aluminum and paper examples, especially for industry.
Note 2: reuse is the dictionary definition of recycle. It is hard to say that reusing is a better option than recycling since recycling's definition is to reuse it. Bring a paper or plastic grocery bag back to the store and you recycled it by reusing it.
Recycling, at least by how I understand it, means to take used products and separate them (mechanically or chemically) into useable, constituent parts.
Reusing, on the other hand, simply means to take the product, with little to no modification, and using it for its given purpose or for something else.
The problem with recycling is that it requires processing. Like you said, if it is done properly, and on an economic scale that would reduce costs and optimize efficiency, it would be beneficial. As it is, recycling isn't handled well enough or done in enough areas that it is making a marked difference. I'm all for recycling, but I think reducing and reusing should be the first line options in conservation of material resources.