I'm not a fan of people stealing other's creative property. despite what numbers one wants to attach to it.
I never cared for economic impact figures anyway.
I'm all for bands that have freely distributed their music, allowed live recording, whatever. It's all about what the artist chooses to do with their property. If they choose to distribute it privately, fine. If they need big studio or industry support to keep working, and thus rely on the studio to dictate distribution, fine.
bear in mind, I'm all for the record industry collapsing into a steaming pile of shit (uh well...not that it would smell any different), but whatever the artists and creators, and massive production teams dependent on such works choose regarding distribution, is fine with me.
Not a fan of thievery, however you want to sugarcoat it.