TPU didn't have a 280, so I referenced the 7950. Look at what I was quoting, connect the dots. I have faith that you can do that...
What's your point? R9 280 is
$150 and HD7950 is $140 on Newegg.
Also, learn how the decibel system works. You are complaining because of 980's 43db compared to 290's 49db? That doesn't mean the 290 is only 12% louder...
Did I compare 980's 43dB to 290's reference? Clearly you are putting words in my mouth.
Ok, now you're saying that he criticized the Sapphire 290X's acoustics? He didn't, I just found the article and read it, since you didn't link it. So throw that accusation out the window.
He clearly said in his 960 review the following:
"The current price/performance king is the R9 290, which, at $270, isn't completely out of reach either. However, the integral difference to me and a ton of users is that NVIDIA's new GTX 960 is so very power efficient,
which makes it run much cooler and quieter than AMD's cards."
I provided a counter-example to his claim where an after-market R9 290 runs cool and quiet. Therefore, his statement is either too limited to specific reference cards or he is intentionally not discussing the existence of after-market R9 290 cards. In effect, it makes 960 look cooler and quieter than it really is, negating the point in his review. I pointed this out. It's a valid criticism.
Then again, this is way off-topic. Per usual when it comes to your posts.
Everything I posted is on-topic.
1. I addressed price/performance
2. I addressed power usage
3. I addressed temperatures
4. I addressed VRAM
5. I addressed absolute performance
You provided no valid counter-arguments against my points, instead calling my posts off-topic. That's not a valid response, sorry.
And now you are claiming we only cater to DIY users? People don't come here with pre-built systems wanting to upgrade? Should we just ignore them, call them peasants? Tell them to upgrade their PSU along with the video card, even if it isn't necessary?
The primary target market of AT sub-forum like ours is definitely not OEMs/wholesalers and pre-built system builders. You focusing on OEMs is just a cop out for ignoring all my points as they relate to the DIY market.
Even when members come and ask for advice for pre-built / OEM systems, in times like those we provide advice like get a $5 PSU adapter for your 450W PSU to run a 280X/290X, you know that
one time when someone like that asked for advice and
you couldn't even provide that answer! Even when people proved to you with professional reviews that his PSU was rated far above his wattage, you refused to believe facts and continued to repeat your opinion. According to you, we should take away that pre-built systems don't have upgradable PSUs, and PSU adapters don't come with videocards and can't be bought! I learned a lot today. You continue to derail my questions/comments instead of addressing my points directly:
You also failed to justify your position how a crappy OEM PSU would be able to power a 960 but not a 7950, didn't address my point on VRAM, nor price/performance, not spending a bit more for longevity with a 960 vs. 290. In other words, you disregarded ALL my points since well you have no solid argument to present. Instead you ended your point about OEMs vs. DIY.
What positive can be said for 960 besides perf/watt and lower power usage against an R9 290?
You ignored price/performance of R9 290 - check
You ignored VRAM advantage for IQ in games - check
You ignored longevity of a card for someone wanting to keep his card for more than 2 years - check
You ignored the massive performance difference at 1080P - check
You ignored that even a crappy PSU would be overwhelmed by a 960 + i5 while 500W PSU can easily be found for $50 on Newegg and will last 5-10 years - check
You even diverted attention to a reference R9 290 when no one even discussed it (implying as if $240-260 after-market R9 290s do not exit) - check
When 960 gets mopped up in future titles at 1080P by an after-market 290, and the 960 is forced to use medium textures because you thought it was a good idea to save $40-60 for a new purchase, I'll just tell you - I told you so!
However, I am not here to sell you a 960 or a 290> I just want to present fair and square information to new PC DIYers that are entering our hobby. In my opinion, providing this information out there is doing them a service. If they compare the data, and choose a 960, no problem. The last thing we want to do on this forum is to hide disadvantages of a certain product from public because it's doing a disservice for us to be impartial as a forum. I do not get $ for promoting NV or AMD cards but I'll criticize things I think warrant criticism - just like I ripped apart reference 7970/290 blowers or 5800 series poor tessellation for anyone who wanted to keep them for longer to enjoy tessellation in DX11 games.
^
That, and it's a great straw man to use for posters seeking to divert attention away from less desireable comparisons when they irrationally favor one brand over another; (e.g. to distract discussion onto meager differences in power consumption in order to prevent discussion about performance per dollar or max performance at a given price point)