I'm just browsing my local newspaper. Geo Prizms are dirt cheap. Like a 99 for $5000 kind of cheap. That's basically a Toyota Corolla under the skin and I think it looks better too. You should be able to find a 96 Accord EX or 97 Accord LX for less than $8000. Perhaps a 96 Camry for well under $8000, but they're so bland.
Personally, I think Accords are the best 4 door cars out there for their overall mix of value, dependability, longevity, economy, and quality. They're far and away #1 in end user sales for a reason. No you crappers, before you start, I'm not brainwashed. I happen to have a lot of experience with a lot of different cars.
Thought you'd be interested to know, there is a 93 BMW 3something in there with like 125,000 miles for $7000.
EDIT: Oops! That Bimmer in the paper is actually a 93 318 (HB, if I'm not mistaken) with 115,000 for $6100.
Also forgot to look at Maximas in the paper. Don't even bother with an Accord V6 when you can get a Maxima. The Pre 98 V6 Accords aren't much faster except in gas suckage. I wouldn't say the car is better than an Accord or Camry, but the engine sure is. You're probably looking at a about a 95-96.