Cheap bar soap. Guys don't need anything more than regular soap. Soap cuts through oily skin, will clean pores, etc. Women need those exfoliating scrubs, tea leaf extracts, etc, since their faces wear makeup all day. Guys don't need, nor should they use, anything but soap unless they have a medical condition such as severe acne.
Quite honestly, since the original post is coming from a guy named ManlyMatt, there is no excuse to use anything but cheap bar soap or leftover shampoo residue which you then also use to shave with.