rsbennett00
Golden Member
- Jul 13, 2014
- 1,023
- 0
- 76
Mandatory 401k? I guess I'll take your word on it but there's nothing that I know of forcing you to do the 401k plan. As for your friend that took bankruptcy, not sure what to think about that one. You can get hardship 401k money per IRS rules and medical is one of them. That story doesn't add up. And I'm not sure your friends in academia even have a 401k plan. Most likely a 403b or 457 plan, typically found in government and school jobs. Don't know the rules on those though.
The 401k was NOT created as a retirement vehicle for the masses, it was intended to be a tax break for the rich. Once employers found out that they could shift the burden of funding retirements from pensions (employers) to the employee, especially by enticing them with a small match, the race to do it was on. There's no law that states that the company even has to do a match with a 401k (I've lost mine in the past with the bad economy).
If you want to tax defer your savings, then you play by the 401k rules. If not, don't put your money in there and do something else with it. Nobody is forcing you into contributing to a 401k plan, but most companies will give you ZERO match if you put ZERO in. That's your choice to put ZERO in, not the company's choice to force you into it.
I asked and yeah it's a 401a. So I take it that's massively different from other 401 plans, that's part of why this is so confusing and I want nothing to do with it. I'll go with you guys and stop thinking 401's are all bad, just some of them.