I love these polls!
nVidia here!
My History: w/ 1-5 point scale, I'll "try" to be fair
ATI 7000 64MB PCI - 1
PNY GF2 MX 64MB - 1
Leadtek nForce 1 IGP - 2 (1st and only kick-ass IGP... for it's time at least)
ATI 7500AIW - 2 (video rippin' was cool, but 3D sucked)
Leadtek GF4 4400ti - 5
nVidia GF4 4600ti (from a DELL) - 3 (the 4400ti OCed much higher)
Sparkle FX 5600NU - 1 (BUNK!)
S/U/M/A 9500pro - 4 (had 2.8ns RAM!!)
ATI 9500pro - 4 (3.0ns RAM, but still good)
PowerColor 9800np - 3 (my 9500pro's were a much better value, had 3.0ns RAM!)
S/U/M/A FX 5900 128mb - 4 (flashed to a 5950)
EVGA 6800 Ultra - 5 (AGP, power hog, but still a 5... and screw value)
EVGA 7800GT (N518) - 5 (SLI)
EVGA 7800GT CO SE (N516) - 5 (SLI)
nVidia got 27/40 or a 67.5% even counting my IGP mobo
ATI got 14/25 or a 56%
ATI would have had a better chance if I would have bought a X8x0 or X1800 XL/XT card, but Crossfire took too long to come out. So I went with nVidia. And I'll stick with nVidia aslong as ATI has those damn hard-to-find X-fire master cards.