Atomic Playboy
Lifer
- Feb 6, 2007
- 16,432
- 1
- 81
Originally posted by: Howard
- toe the speakers in so that their axes cross in front of the listening position - this lowers the amplitude of the earliest reflections which can be detrimental to sound quality and imaging (depends on the room shape and dimensions though)
I did a bit of research on speaker placement when setting up my home theater, and I've done a bit more after reading this statement, and I have to say that the only person I've seen recommend setting the speaker toe-in infront of the listening position is you. Where did you get this information? I'm willing to concede the point, I'm just curious as I cannot find a single guide that suggests this.
For reference:
Recommendation 1:
Recommendation 2:Adjust the position of the target itself to correlate with the speaker manufacturers recommendation for where the speaker output should intersect. Speakers requiring a large amount of toe-in will intersect at or just behind the listener, that point moves further back when less toe-in is indicated. Some manufacturers are adamant regarding the amount of toe-in, others are less specific in their recommendations. In general, more toe-in increases center focus, but reducing stage width. Less toe-in widens the stage, but center focus will be sacrificed if you go too far. Sometimes it's a balancing act based on the room, the speaker and the preference of the listener.
Everything else I found merely reinforced the idea that toe-in was completely dependent on the speaker, so you should check the manufacturer's recommendation or experiment yourself with what sounded best. The only article that mentioned positioning at all placed the toe-in at or behind the listening position, not in front of it. Where did you find that the ideal toe-in was in front of the listening position? Is it specific to the speaker you use, and would it apply in the OP's scenario?There is no 'general' home theater speaker placement rule in that this depends on a number of factors. In particular, it depends on the sound dispersion pattern of the speakers in question.
I'm not trying to call you out, I'm legitimately curious. My home theater room is being redone, at which point I will start setting things up again, and I hadn't considered speaker toe-in to the degree you suggest. I'll probably keep it wide just because I want the expanded soundstage for when company is over, but I still like to experiment with new things.