KOTOR was the last game that was shockingly good and really blew me away. If that's the question being asked. The story twist blew me away because I didn't see it coming at all.
Hmmmm Last game...
Has to be the Mass Effect Series.
BUT... the BIGGEST jaw drop (Sorry OP... Have to go off on a tangent and stray from LAST)
My vote is KOTOR 1. YET, I could not play it again for the "Other side"... I went goody 2 shoes the first playthrough.
Wanted to go evil.
The queueing up the actions. The story. The vesting in my toon.
All sucked me in.
And yet KOTOR 2.... Didnt hold me at all.
A VERY close second......
Baulders Gate. THAC0 Its all about the THAC0...
And WHO can forget finding that ring in the abandoned field at the very begining.
MAN that spread through the net like crabs in a whore house.
RIGHT then, I knew this was a gonna be a great ride.
Go for the eyes Boo......
Gaming goodness.
And Graphics NOT a part of my decision... For any of the 3.
My PC is USUALLY 2 plus years behind the curve. Married and 5 kids...
I took what I could afford back then.
Even today (My baby is late 20's....) I just upgraded to a 2 GB EVGA 650 LOL.. For 95 bucks..Best Buy December clearance rack.
Do I need a 660 TI (Or whatever) for $350? Not me... But that is me. To each his own.
I dont need 5000 by 2000 res and 85 times anti-alias.
Story and PLAY.. Thats what gets me.