I don't have any of those two but use a digital camera that does videos. I don't like the fact that the flip video types don't have any stabilization. So I just found a DC that I like with HD video and bought that one. Mine is a Sony DSC-H20 that has a 10X optical zoom and Optical stabilization. I can also zoom while recording video which a lot of them can't do. It's a little bigger and does only 720p. But for my good stuff, I have a HD camcorder.