thereaderrabbit
Senior member
- Jan 3, 2001
- 444
- 0
- 0
Originally posted by: mwtgg
Originally posted by: kogase
Originally posted by: mwtgg
It's not "believing in nothing". Saying that presumes that the theists are correct. "Oh well you have to believe in something if I do!" It's extremely faulty logic. There is no belief involved in saying there is no god.
Okay, prove to me there's no God. If you can't, but still say there is none, you have faith.
No, theists made the assertion. It's up to them to prove it.
Originally posted by: kogase
Originally posted by: mwtgg
Originally posted by: kogase
Originally posted by: mwtgg
It's not "believing in nothing". Saying that presumes that the theists are correct. "Oh well you have to believe in something if I do!" It's extremely faulty logic. There is no belief involved in saying there is no god.
Okay, prove to me there's no God. If you can't, but still say there is none, you have faith.
No, theists made the assertion. It's up to them to prove it.
But if you say without a shadow of a doubt that it doesn't exist, you have to prove that as well.
Originally posted by: mwtgg
Why should someone be forced to disprove a claim that can't even be validated by those who make it?
Originally posted by: kogase
Originally posted by: mwtgg
Why should someone be forced to disprove a claim that can't even be validated by those who make it?
No one's forcing you. But if you want to make the statement that God does not exist, you have to prove it.
Originally posted by: Nebor
Easily proved.
Children are raped every day. Any being capable of stopping such actions would. Since those actions occur anyway, it's clear that there is no God. Or, alternately, that Jesus is a pedophile.
Originally posted by: kogase
Originally posted by: mwtgg
Why should someone be forced to disprove a claim that can't even be validated by those who make it?
No one's forcing you. But if you want to make the statement that God does not exist, you have to prove it.
Originally posted by: mwtgg
Originally posted by: kogase
Originally posted by: mwtgg
Why should someone be forced to disprove a claim that can't even be validated by those who make it?
No one's forcing you. But if you want to make the statement that God does not exist, you have to prove it.
Ok, argue with my diction, not my content. Nice tactics.
I'm saying, how can I prove there is no God when you can't even prove there is one? Theists made the claim first, back it up.
Originally posted by: kogase
Originally posted by: mwtgg
Originally posted by: kogase
Originally posted by: mwtgg
Why should someone be forced to disprove a claim that can't even be validated by those who make it?
No one's forcing you. But if you want to make the statement that God does not exist, you have to prove it.
Ok, argue with my diction, not my content. Nice tactics.
I'm saying, how can I prove there is no God when you can't even prove there is one? Theists made the claim first, back it up.
Exactly. You can't prove there is no God. Hence my other comment in this thread about (at least in the context of God) being unable to "prove a negative".
Originally posted by: mwtgg
But it's not up to the atheists to prove anything. Are you stupid or do you just play it on the internet?
Originally posted by: kogase
Originally posted by: mwtgg
But it's not up to the atheists to prove anything. Are you stupid or do you just play it on the internet?
Nobody is asking you to prove anything. I'm just saying you can't, and therefore can't make the proclomation that there is no God.
Originally posted by: mwtgg
Ok, why do I bother? Honestly. Why? Are you intentionally being dense or what?