Pretty much my thoughts too but on the bolded I wonder if people complaining about privacy stuff even own a smart phone and if they do, do they complain about having to turn off location settings and contact sync as well?
I've bit*ed about Android in other forums.
However, there's a drastic difference in usage between my phone and my desktop PC. I use smartphone for phone calls, SMS, gmail and everything else is basically for sh*ts and giggles - check news, forums on the internet, media player, a couple simple games, weather app etc.
Here's some stuff I do on my PC that I would never do on my phone:
1. I connect to my work desktop PC via VPN. Technically IT doesn't even allow this (VPN allowed only on company issued laptops), but management turns a blind eye.
2. Internet banking - stuff like accessing my bank accounts, online brokerage services for investing, RRSP account (Canadian 401K) etc. No way would I do this on a phone.
3. Filing tax returns and keeping all the slips and whatnot going back quite a few years. I'm not storing this on the phone or any clouds.
4. I have lots of various documents from PR/citizenship process like passport copies, forms with personal data, visas etc., all stored on my PC. Canadian government already has all these, I see no reason I should share them with Microsoft.
This is from the top of my head; if I looked through my PC, I'm sure I'd find more examples. I simply hold PC OS to a higher standard because I use it for more serious and more sensitive stuff. Right now I wouldn't feel comfortable doing this on Win 10 wondering if I've missed some checkbox somewhere, or if MS interprets 'turned off' as 'mostly turned off'.
Although the bigger issue for me is forced auto updates, I will not get on board with that, I've posted in the thread about it. All-in-all, if things don't change, my next desktop machine will be some Linux distro. Linux only lacks in gaming, and my gaming time has really gone down lately, I've bought 4-5 games since 2008, and 0 in the last 2 years, so not much sacrifice. If I were really big on gaming and I wanted DX12, I'd just have a dedicated gaming machine used for nothing else, basically like a console. But I think it's sad for MS if Win 10 is reduced to such purpose.