Why is saving money so hard?

Page 8 - Seeking answers? Join the AnandTech community: where nearly half-a-million members share solutions and discuss the latest tech.

Safeway

Lifer
Jun 22, 2004
12,081
9
81
Face it, you're living a more luxurious lifestyle than you should. You just don't see it, because you're privileged.

I am definitely privileged. I was born white and male, and I had parents that took an active role in my life and motivated me to get my engineering and law degrees.

That said, the $10k/month example truly is hypothetical. My wife and I bring home substantially more than that.
 

z1ggy

Lifer
May 17, 2008
10,004
63
91
I am definitely privileged. I was born white and male, and I had parents that took an active role in my life and motivated me to get my engineering and law degrees.

That said, the $10k/month example truly is hypothetical. My wife and I bring home substantially more than that.

Good for you, at least you're not a burden on society.

However, a lot of the things you listed were grossly over estimated in price, and on top of that, are straight up luxuries if one is trying to be frugal. New cars? What's wrong with 3-4 years old with decent miles? $500 for cable, cell phones and utilities? That's insane. Ditch the cable completely, get pay as you go phones, and turn the heat/ac off more.

Lastly, (I didn't check Zillow because quite frankly I don't care enough, but ) according to a salary calculate I checked to find out that $10k a month here is equal to about $13k where you live, tells me $1600 for a 2 bedroom house is nuts. That calculator told me real estate in Dallas TX costs 41% less than it does here. I own a 2 bed room house and it cost me $156k to buy @ 4.75%. My payment with taxes AND insurance, is just a hair over $1200 a month. My house in TX would then likely only be costing you around $600-700 per month. It's not in a shitty area here either.

Again, you just need to see that the $10k you think doesn't get you anything, actually does.
 
Last edited:

TheSlamma

Diamond Member
Sep 6, 2005
7,625
5
81
I am definitely privileged. I was born white and male, and I had parents that took an active role in my life and motivated me to get my engineering and law degrees.

That said, the $10k/month example truly is hypothetical. My wife and I bring home substantially more than that.
Hey dude, as long as your ego feels better we're all good here.
 

Safeway

Lifer
Jun 22, 2004
12,081
9
81
Good for you, at least you're not a burden on society.

However, a lot of the things you listed were grossly over estimated in price, and on top of that, are straight up luxuries if one is trying to be frugal. New cars? What's wrong with 3-4 years old with decent miles? $500 for cable, cell phones and utilities? That's insane. Ditch the cable completely, get pay as you go phones, and turn the heat/ac off more.

Lastly, (I didn't check Zillow because quite frankly I don't care enough, but ) according to a salary calculate I checked to find out that $10k a month here is equal to about $13k where you live, tells me $1600 for a 2 bedroom house is nuts. That calculator told me real estate in Dallas TX costs 41% less than it does here. I own a 2 bed room house and it cost me $156k to buy @ 4.75%. My payment with taxes AND insurance, is just a hair over $1200 a month. My house in TX would then likely only be costing you around $600-700 per month. It's not in a shitty area here either.

Again, you just need to see that the $10k you think doesn't get you anything, actually does.

I live in a decent part of Dallas, Lakewood proper. The neighborhoods that flank my neighborhood are going insane right now. $260k for an 1,100 square foot home built in the 1950s. $360k for a 1,600 square foot home that sold on the first day of the MLS listing for 15% over asking price ($420k). This is NOT one of the "nice" neighborhoods. It is a modest neighborhood.

A friend from high school just bought a home in Garland (King of the Hill). It was listed for $125k, but they had to put in a $155k offer to win. They had been looking for 2 years in and around Dallas, and that is all that they could afford. I think that your data on the Dallas real estate market is outdated or simply incorrect.

Apartments are nearing $150 per square foot, and good luck finding a home in Dallas for under $200 per square foot. M-Streets is at $250, OLH is at $200, LH is at $200.
 

SketchMaster

Diamond Member
Feb 23, 2005
3,100
149
116
Safeway,

With all due respect to the work you've put in to get to where you are now, I think you really don't have an accurate perspective of what it's like for the majority of people out there. A lot of hard working and well educated people make sub 100K salaries regardless of where they live. A lot of your monthly costs estimates are very, very high. As Z1g pointed out, most of us can't help but wonder what the heck you're doing to spend that much.

$1,000/mo for food? My monthly food budget for just myself is $150. I shop sales at Sprouts or Target, cook most of my meals, and eat out less than once a week.

Buying two new cars at $30K each? My god, Man... Buy two 2-4yr old cars: a small 4-door for work/groceries and a minivan for hauling the kids. You'll spend no more than $40k for both and save on insurance to boot.

$500 for internet and util? I live in Austin, so I know how hot it gets in TX, but I keep my apt at 78* and run a dehumidifier to keep the room feeling comfy at 50% humidity. I spend maybe $68-$75/mo on electricity to cool a 750Sqft apt. My internet costs me $50/mo for 100/10 (Yay for Google forcing competition) and I don't bother with TV. Cellphone for work is free, and I pay $55/mo for my personal line with unlimited talk/text and 1GB data through AT&T.

I get the housing, I do. ATX is going nuts right now, so I'm dreading to see how much it's going to cost me to buy a home in a good(ish) area come next year. That being said, it's really up to each person to decide what home they are willing to pay for; but most of us have to look in the not so great areas because $250K is the max we can bite off.

Safeway, don't get me wrong, If you have that kind of money to buy luxuries then more power to ya. You should, however, realize that your standard of living is way higher than what 85% of the US actually thinks is normal.
 
Last edited:

Belegost

Golden Member
Feb 20, 2001
1,807
19
81
So you are financing used vehicles. A new Honda Accord, over 5 years, would be over $400/month and the $100/month total insurance premium seems accurate in light of your premium.

No one has commented on my statement that those capable of earning such an income (household income derived from both husband and wife) are likely weighed down by student loan debt to the tune of $2,500/month over 10 years. They would not qualify for most debt relief plans, such as an extended payout schedule or income-sensitive payments.

$10k/month take home isn't nothing, but it isn't a life of wealth and luxury as others stated. It's a life of beige and normalcy.

Because $2500/month in student loan debt is ridiculous?

As of late last year, the average in TX was 25K for students graduating last year. Let's say you double that for each person, it only adds up to 100K total debt. Admittedly I consolidated my loans a couple years ago at 2.4%, but even at higher rates today you're talking about ~1k/month. For the more average couple, 500/month.

And yes, brand-new Accords are a luxury purchase. Buy them at half price with 2 years and maybe 30-40k on the odometer.

1600/month before taxes and homeowner's insurance supports a loan of 340K. A quick look around the market in Dallas at some of the top 10 suburbs on realtor.com shows 3/2 1800+ sq ft homes going in Frisco, Murray, Allen areas that were listed in the last 30 days for less than that. And not a few, over 130 properties for less than 300K listed in the past month. Hell, about 60 of those were under $250K.

So it seems like 1600/month + taxes and insurance for a modest 2 bed house is not accurate either.

As someone who has a family of 4 on 7K/month take home, I agree it's not wealthy, but even living in an area with 30 points higher cost of living index than Dallas, and a 2400/month mortgage/taxes/insurance bill, we still manage to contribute 700/month to retirement/savings.
 

Safeway

Lifer
Jun 22, 2004
12,081
9
81
Because $2500/month in student loan debt is ridiculous?

As of late last year, the average in TX was 25K for students graduating last year. Let's say you double that for each person, it only adds up to 100K total debt. Admittedly I consolidated my loans a couple years ago at 2.4%, but even at higher rates today you're talking about ~1k/month. For the more average couple, 500/month.

That level of student loan debt likely wouldn't support wage earners capable of earning $10k/month. We are talking about professional school, masters, etc. This average is closer to $75k or $100k. I had (stupid) friends that graduated with $200k in loans, and I know a freshly minted oral surgeon with $580k in student loans. The latter will have a $7k/month minimum payment. Her program was long, expensive, and unpaid. She had to not only pay for tuition, but all living expenses. She was not very frugal.

And yes, brand-new Accords are a luxury purchase. Buy them at half price with 2 years and maybe 30-40k on the odometer.

A Lexus or BMW or Mercedes or Acura is a luxury purchase. A Honda is a reasonable purchase. Sure, go with a CPO to save some money.

1600/month before taxes and homeowner's insurance supports a loan of 340K. A quick look around the market in Dallas at some of the top 10 suburbs on realtor.com shows 3/2 1800+ sq ft homes going in Frisco, Murray, Allen areas that were listed in the last 30 days for less than that. And not a few, over 130 properties for less than 300K listed in the past month. Hell, about 60 of those were under $250K.

So it seems like 1600/month + taxes and insurance for a modest 2 bed house is not accurate either.

These places are not Dallas. Dallas is Dallas. There are very few safe neighborhoods in Dallas and, within those neighborhoods, there are very few homes available.

Also, $1,600/month before tax and insurance is a $250k home at 3%.

As someone who has a family of 4 on 7K/month take home, I agree it's not wealthy, but even living in an area with 30 points higher cost of living index than Dallas, and a 2400/month mortgage/taxes/insurance bill, we still manage to contribute 700/month to retirement/savings.

People are acting like you'd pull up to the dock in a 911 Turbo at this level of income. In reality, you pull up to Costco in a Honda Accord to do some bulk shopping.
 

SMOGZINN

Lifer
Jun 17, 2005
14,218
4,446
136
1600/month before taxes and homeowner's insurance supports a loan of 340K. A quick look around the market in Dallas at some of the top 10 suburbs on realtor.com shows 3/2 1800+ sq ft homes going in Frisco, Murray, Allen areas that were listed in the last 30 days for less than that. And not a few, over 130 properties for less than 300K listed in the past month. Hell, about 60 of those were under $250K.

I live in a nice neighborhood in Dallas, in a 2400sq/ft, 3 bed/2.5 bath, attached 2 car garage, on a lot and a half, and pay $1300/mo. His numbers are over inflated.
 

Ns1

No Lifer
Jun 17, 2001
55,414
1,574
126
The neighborhoods that flank my neighborhood are going insane right now. $260k for an 1,100 square foot home built in the 1950s. $360k for a 1,600 square foot home that sold on the first day of the MLS listing for 15% over asking price ($420k). This is NOT one of the "nice" neighborhoods. It is a modest neighborhood.

that's considered insane?

:awe:
 

WhoBeDaPlaya

Diamond Member
Sep 15, 2000
7,414
401
126
Apartments are nearing $150 per square foot, and good luck finding a home in Dallas for under $200 per square foot. M-Streets is at $250, OLH is at $200, LH is at $200.
^ Confirmed. A 625sq-ft apt in my complex (edge of Farmers Branch and Addison, just north of 635 near Valley View / Galleria) sold for $80K, built in the 1960s
That said, a friend got lucky and got a new 3500sq-ft house in Murphy for $287K last year. Not a fancy builder like Toll Brothers, but still good.
 

Safeway

Lifer
Jun 22, 2004
12,081
9
81
Safeway,

With all due respect to the work you've put in to get to where you are now, I think you really don't have an accurate perspective of what it's like for the majority of people out there. A lot of hard working and well educated people make sub 100K salaries regardless of where they live. A lot of your monthly costs estimates are very, very high. As Z1g pointed out, most of us can't help but wonder what the heck you're doing to spend that much.

$1,000/mo for food? My monthly food budget for just myself is $150. I shop sales at Sprouts or Target, cook most of my meals, and eat out less than once a week.

Buying two new cars at $30K each? My god, Man... Buy two 2-4yr old cars: a small 4-door for work/groceries and a minivan for hauling the kids. You'll spend no more than $40k for both and save on insurance to boot.

$500 for internet and util? I live in Austin, so I know how hot it gets in TX, but I keep my apt at 78* and run a dehumidifier to keep the room feeling comfy at 50% humidity. I spend maybe $68-$75/mo on electricity to cool a 750Sqft apt. My internet costs me $50/mo for 100/10 (Yay for Google forcing competition) and I don't bother with TV. Cellphone for work is free, and I pay $55/mo for my personal line with unlimited talk/text and 1GB data through AT&T.

I get the housing, I do. ATX is going nuts right now, so I'm dreading to see how much it's going to cost me to buy a home in a good(ish) area come next year. That being said, it's really up to each person to decide what home they are willing to pay for; but most of us have to look in the not so great areas because $250K is the max we can bite off.

Safeway, don't get me wrong, If you have that kind of money to buy luxuries then more power to ya. You should, however, realize that your standard of living is way higher than what 85% of the US actually thinks is normal.

From my initial post-graduate experience, they aren't ridiculously high estimates. You pay $200/month, but you are heating and cooling a small space - and don't have to pick up a cell phone bill. Now add a wife and kid. Children can't deal with 78F as well. If you work from home, you have to climate control 24/7.

We do spend too much on food, but the convenience is currently worth the expenditure. My example assumes a decent amount of restaurant eating.

As for ATX, a friend of mine just bought a single family home a stones throw west of downtown. It is a tiny 900 square foot thing with a window unit. He paid $600k. Another friend bought in downtown for an obscene amount. A third, more reasonable, friend just rented a 3/3 detached town home near Airport and MLK for $2400/month. You know how sketchy that area is.
 

Safeway

Lifer
Jun 22, 2004
12,081
9
81
I live in a nice neighborhood in Dallas, in a 2400sq/ft, 3 bed/2.5 bath, attached 2 car garage, on a lot and a half, and pay $1300/mo. His numbers are over inflated.

When did you buy? What neighborhood? 30-year mortgage?
 

Safeway

Lifer
Jun 22, 2004
12,081
9
81
^ Confirmed. A 625sq-ft apt in my complex (edge of Farmers Branch and Addison, just north of 635 near Valley View / Galleria) sold for $80K, built in the 1960s
That said, a friend got lucky and got a new 3500sq-ft house in Murphy for $287K last year. Not a fancy builder like Toll Brothers, but still good.

Exactly, and the 'burbs ain't Dallas. I live in Lakewood and can't imagine having to commute further than I currently do.
 

Belegost

Golden Member
Feb 20, 2001
1,807
19
81
That level of student loan debt likely wouldn't support wage earners capable of earning $10k/month. We are talking about professional school, masters, etc. This average is closer to $75k or $100k. I had (stupid) friends that graduated with $200k in loans, and I know a freshly minted oral surgeon with $580k in student loans. The latter will have a $7k/month minimum payment. Her program was long, expensive, and unpaid. She had to not only pay for tuition, but all living expenses. She was not very frugal.
I did 6 years of grad school for my doctorate in EE (finished in 2010), I'm aware of the costs, at the same time if you're paying everything on loans, you're doing it wrong. Work a job/TA/RA on campus, apply for every fellowship imaginable, and make sure you're near the top of the GPA chart and grad school will be paid for. Ultimately though, if you take out those sort of loans, you spend 10 years with a reduced lifestyle in return for the 30+ years of increased earnings.

A Lexus or BMW or Mercedes or Acura is a luxury purchase. A Honda is a reasonable purchase. Sure, go with a CPO to save some money.
Paying the off-the-lot depreciation on a new car is a luxury, let someone else soak that cost.

These places are not Dallas. Dallas is Dallas. There are very few safe neighborhoods in Dallas and, within those neighborhoods, there are very few homes available.

Also, $1,600/month before tax and insurance is a $250k home at 3%.
I just ran the amortization on $250K at 3% - 1600 for a 15 year loan, but a more reasonable expectation is a 30 year at 3.9% - 1100/month before taxes/insurance. The 30 year makes a lot of sense if you're also paying down student loans, and it's a better plan long-term to take advantage of the ridiculously low rates now, and push out the payoff to times with more inflated currency.

People are acting like you'd pull up to the dock in a 911 Turbo at this level of income. In reality, you pull up to Costco in a Honda Accord to do some bulk shopping.
This part is too true, a lot of people think 130K/year somehow corresponds to Scrooge McDuck money pools...
 

brianmanahan

Lifer
Sep 2, 2006
24,300
5,729
136
I am definitely privileged. I was born white and male, and I had parents that took an active role in my life and motivated me to get my engineering and law degrees.

That said, the $10k/month example truly is hypothetical. My wife and I bring home substantially more than that.

You remind me a little more of alky with every post
 

Engineer

Elite Member
Oct 9, 1999
39,234
701
126
This part is too true, a lot of people think 130K/year somehow corresponds to Scrooge McDuck money pools...

LOL....nowhere near that. It's the idea that some people have that you must pull in 130K after taxes to even scape by that has me scratching my head. While getting 130K after tax is doing it right.....just getting by on 130k is doing it WAY WRONG.
 

TheSlamma

Diamond Member
Sep 6, 2005
7,625
5
81
I live in a decent part of Dallas, Lakewood proper.
You live in a wealthy neighborhood.

Sorry but your grasp on reality is gone and probably wasn't there to begin with. You live in a nice hood and it sounds like your parents were well off.

My wife and I do well for ourselves and live in one of the top 5 nicest neighborhoods in Denver, we live a few blocks away from the Governors personal house and a few other Denver elites. Even with that we sock away way more money per month than we ever thought we would be making given our backgrounds and HS diploma educations. We live modestly and just never forgot where we came from (poor families). We saved up for a long time to feel comfortable with affording this neighborhood. Either one of us could lose their job and we could live off just one of our incomes. You are seriously living beyond the means of most people.

And don't give me the Dallas insane prices gig, Denver is only matched by San Fran in crazy price increases right now.

Again there is nothing wrong with any of that, but to tell us 10K is some kind of chump change per month is just not grounded in 90% of Americans reality is all.
 

Safeway

Lifer
Jun 22, 2004
12,081
9
81
You live in a wealthy neighborhood.

Sorry but your grasp on reality is gone and probably wasn't there to begin with. You live in a nice hood and it sounds like your parents were well off.

My wife and I do well for ourselves and live in one of the top 5 nicest neighborhoods in Denver, we live a few blocks away from the Governors personal house and a few other Denver elites. Even with that we sock away way more money per month than we ever thought we would be making given our backgrounds and HS diploma educations. We live modestly and just never forgot where we came from (poor families). We saved up for a long time to feel comfortable with affording this neighborhood. Either one of us could lose their job and we could live off just one of our incomes. You are seriously living beyond the means of most people.

And don't give me the Dallas insane prices gig, Denver is only matched by San Fran in crazy price increases right now.

Again there is nothing wrong with any of that, but to tell us 10K is some kind of chump change per month is just not grounded in 90% of Americans reality is all.

I don't disagree with anything you have said, except regarding my upbringing. My parents were making around $40k to $50k pre-tax (combined) for the majority of my childhood (adjusted for inflation). We were living in a bad part of town, my friends were in legitimate gangs, I carried a knife to school for personal protection, etc. It wasn't until high school that they switched gears and career paths and made over $100k pre-tax (combined) for the first time.

In the abstract, I know that there is a logical gap between my personal knowledge of my upbringing on about $3k/month take-home (with two children, no less) and my current belief that $10k/month is required to live somewhat comfortably, but in the absence of excessive luxuries. After I graduated, money seemed to be so meaningless and valueless. What I initially thought would provide for a nice lifestyle, a $160k big law job in IP, only allowed me to pay the bills and save for the future, with some discretionary income remaining. I've since left and started my own IP consulting firm, which is much more rewarding.

I read an article recently that said that the more money you have, the wealthier your friends become, and the poorer you feel. I have friends and acquintances that are worth $250m, $700m, all the way to $12b+. Whereas my net worth may be 10x or even 100x some people, these guys have a net worth that is nearly 1000x mine. And that 1000x margin is purely in the excessive and expendable spectrum.
 
Last edited:

Safeway

Lifer
Jun 22, 2004
12,081
9
81
While I think he may be out of touch with reality on this subject, it's not even close to being another Alky....not even close.

Alkemyst and I butted heads in pretty much every thread we both posted in. He was beyond a tool bag, it was simply willful ignorance in every thread. He was also a perpetual liar, claiming to be a practicing pharmacist (which allowed him to buy his used up M3), but later claiming to be in pharmacy school. I think neither was true.

Thank you for saying this. It means a lot.
 
sale-70-410-exam    | Exam-200-125-pdf    | we-sale-70-410-exam    | hot-sale-70-410-exam    | Latest-exam-700-603-Dumps    | Dumps-98-363-exams-date    | Certs-200-125-date    | Dumps-300-075-exams-date    | hot-sale-book-C8010-726-book    | Hot-Sale-200-310-Exam    | Exam-Description-200-310-dumps?    | hot-sale-book-200-125-book    | Latest-Updated-300-209-Exam    | Dumps-210-260-exams-date    | Download-200-125-Exam-PDF    | Exam-Description-300-101-dumps    | Certs-300-101-date    | Hot-Sale-300-075-Exam    | Latest-exam-200-125-Dumps    | Exam-Description-200-125-dumps    | Latest-Updated-300-075-Exam    | hot-sale-book-210-260-book    | Dumps-200-901-exams-date    | Certs-200-901-date    | Latest-exam-1Z0-062-Dumps    | Hot-Sale-1Z0-062-Exam    | Certs-CSSLP-date    | 100%-Pass-70-383-Exams    | Latest-JN0-360-real-exam-questions    | 100%-Pass-4A0-100-Real-Exam-Questions    | Dumps-300-135-exams-date    | Passed-200-105-Tech-Exams    | Latest-Updated-200-310-Exam    | Download-300-070-Exam-PDF    | Hot-Sale-JN0-360-Exam    | 100%-Pass-JN0-360-Exams    | 100%-Pass-JN0-360-Real-Exam-Questions    | Dumps-JN0-360-exams-date    | Exam-Description-1Z0-876-dumps    | Latest-exam-1Z0-876-Dumps    | Dumps-HPE0-Y53-exams-date    | 2017-Latest-HPE0-Y53-Exam    | 100%-Pass-HPE0-Y53-Real-Exam-Questions    | Pass-4A0-100-Exam    | Latest-4A0-100-Questions    | Dumps-98-365-exams-date    | 2017-Latest-98-365-Exam    | 100%-Pass-VCS-254-Exams    | 2017-Latest-VCS-273-Exam    | Dumps-200-355-exams-date    | 2017-Latest-300-320-Exam    | Pass-300-101-Exam    | 100%-Pass-300-115-Exams    |
http://www.portvapes.co.uk/    | http://www.portvapes.co.uk/    |