Originally posted by: arswihart
As I've said a million times, Asus is an average mobo maker at best. IMO, MSI and Gigabyte are tied for the worst mobo makers out there. I hope you are ok. After that fire, I would never buy an Asus product again.
I'm going to have to call shens on this. ASUS is a great manufacturer with horrid tech support (like most of them). I've had excellent success with ASUS and Abit products, and recommend both over anything else. Sure there's the odd dud here and there (like all manufacturers) - that's why they do RMA's! I've found Epox does RMA's the easiest, but I had a pretty high failure rate (3 of 5 Epox boards I purchased/assembled PC's with developed problems over a 3 year span). I've only had to RMA two or three ASUSes (out of 20+) and knock on wood, I've never had a faulty Abit.
When dealing with any of these companies and trying to get an RMA, don't even bother mentioning the PSU because this is the type of crap all of these companies will try to pull - blame you.
Just simply call them and say: I got this ASUS board and when I plugged it in the corner sparked and actually caught on fire! If they ask you what PSU you used, just say it was a quality PSU. If they push then just give them the brand name. No matter what you can get them to RMA the board - just be firm.
I've RMA'ed an ASUS board that I bought off this message board before (one worked for a couple weeks then refused to turn on; after an RMA it was fine). You don't need a proof of purchase or anything, which saves hassles.
If you can't afford $15 to ship a >$100 motherboard back because it is defective, then I'm sorry to say tough luck. You can't nickle and dime out on shipping on a $500 PC; problems happen and no company has a 0% defect rate.
It's like hard drives. Almost everyone has a bias towards or against a couple companies when the technology is very similar. Most modern hard drives, no matter the brand, will start pushing up the dasies in 5-6 years (although the fluid bearings are better than the previous mechanical bearings, which would often get extremely loud after ~4 years of use).