YAFFT: Who to keep SA or LJ2

[CtK]

im allowed to keep one RB in my keeper league
i have Shaun Alexander, Larry Johnson, and Lamont Jordan.
so who should i keep??

i kinda think Shaun Alexander played good this year cause he wants a HUGE contract.
so im leaning towards LJ2

 

[Shlong]

SA for the consistent #'s he's put up.

 

[jlbenedict]

what is a "Keeper" league?

 

[Shlong]

Originally posted by: jlbenedict
what is a "Keeper" league?

Leagues where you get to keep most of the players you had in the previous season.

 

[BrokenVisage]

Oh man.. it's between Larry Johnson and Shaun Alexander and I'm going to say keep LJ even if Holmes wants to come back next season.

 

[vi edit]

Holy crap. Please tell me you won your league with those three!

Can you wait till next year to decide? I'd see what happens with Priest (I doubt he'll be back) and also see where Alexander signs.

LJ has DOMINATED the NFL the last nine weeks. Tiki Barber has better yards, but LJ has more TD's. He's going to be a #1 draft next year in some leagues.

Tough call.

 

[jammur21]

Alexander

There are two problems with Larry. The KC offensive line, while one of the best in football, is not getting any younger. They will continue to have injury problems next year.
Also Tony Gonzalez is a much bigger target for the Chiefs' offense in the red zone than Seattle's Jermey Stevens, so you're going to lose more TD's with Larry Johnson

 

[waynehead]

Alexander

even though he was in a contract year, he has proven what he can do over a full season before. he's a red zone machine for the seahawks too. i love larry johnson but this year and last year were partial seasons. you can't ignore what a full football season can do to a running back. on top of that, there's alwasy the penn state running back curse!!!

 

[CtK]

Originally posted by: vi_edit
Holy crap. Please tell me you won your league with those three!

Can you wait till next year to decide? I'd see what happens with Priest (I doubt he'll be back) and also see where Alexander signs.

LJ has DOMINATED the NFL the last nine weeks. Tiki Barber has better yards, but LJ has more TD's. He's going to be a #1 draft next year in some leagues.

Tough call.

Yes i did win my league