YAGT: Should I make her pay me back?

[oogabooga]

I'm pretty torn on this one. If you want it back, go ask them for it back.

It seems shady to give your GF or perhaps just friend with benefit) a phone, then ask for it back, as said in the thread, why would you want it back if the relationship had bombed. 100 dollars or not, i dont think i would want it back. Or even ask for it back and appear like an ass.

 

[Zysoclaplem]

It's your phone. Ask her to get it back for you from her parents. If she can't use it, then what use is it to her or them? If they won't give it back, give them hell.

 

[HonkeyDonk]

You sound like a heartless whiny jerk.

Your gf's parents sound like a bunch of idiots.

You all should just stop breathing. You make having a gf sound like a chore/task. grow up.

 

[TitanDiddly]

I get a feeling that we are going to end up Syringered.

 

[TuxDave]

Call it a hunch, but perhaps the parents really don't like you hanging around with her. Especially since you're bragging about having pictures of her doing.......

I sympathize with the parents. They don't want you seeing her and they just beat your little gimmick to get around them.

 

[FinalFantasy]

Originally posted by: Drakkon
ummm ask the parents for YOUR phone back? you bought it, you own it, you pay for it, it is yours.

after watching more judge judy, hatchet, joe, etc than i could take last week it was clear that whoever paid the bills for the phone owned the phone, unless the person making calls charged up entirely way too much.

Agreed.

 

[RbSX]

Originally posted by: TuxDave
Call it a hunch, but perhaps the parents really don't like you hanging around with her. Especially since you're bragging about having pictures of her doing.......

I sympathize with the parents. They don't want you seeing her and they just beat your little gimmick to get around them.

Read one of my above posts. I don't have pictures of her DOING anything. I've got pictures of her in the hottub, other than that nada.

Edit: Summarily, they don't like any guys except for guys in their church. Her parents have been so stringent/overbearing on her that she's rebelled against absolutely everything her parents believe in.

It's not just me.. it's all guys that aren't asian and don't bible thump.

 

[mwtgg]

Hmm, sounds to me like you're a CR.



Good luck with that whole cell phone thing.

 

[TuxDave]

Originally posted by: RyanSengara

Originally posted by: TuxDave
Call it a hunch, but perhaps the parents really don't like you hanging around with her. Especially since you're bragging about having pictures of her doing.......

I sympathize with the parents. They don't want you seeing her and they just beat your little gimmick to get around them.

Read one of my above posts. I don't have pictures of her DOING anything. I've got pictures of her in the hottub, other than that nada.

Edit: Summarily, they don't like any guys except for guys in their church. Her parents have been so stringent/overbearing on her that she's rebelled against absolutely everything her parents believe in.

It's not just me.. it's all guys that aren't asian and don't bible thump.

I see, my bad. But nonetheless, if I had to guess, they simply don't trust that you'll be a good influence for their daughter or take good care of her. I won't argue whether or not they have the right to act as the date filter, but it's something you need to think about. It'll probably be harder for you to gain their trust, but if you believe she's worth the work of gaining the trust of her parents, then you'll figure something out.

btw... you shouldn't make HER pay you back. I'm lazy and so I would suggest taking the loss. If not, then ask her to talk to her parents to give the phone back so she can give it back to you. But don't make her pay you unless you're really through with her.

 

[RbSX]

Originally posted by: TuxDave

Originally posted by: RyanSengara

Originally posted by: TuxDave
Call it a hunch, but perhaps the parents really don't like you hanging around with her. Especially since you're bragging about having pictures of her doing.......

I sympathize with the parents. They don't want you seeing her and they just beat your little gimmick to get around them.

Read one of my above posts. I don't have pictures of her DOING anything. I've got pictures of her in the hottub, other than that nada.

Edit: Summarily, they don't like any guys except for guys in their church. Her parents have been so stringent/overbearing on her that she's rebelled against absolutely everything her parents believe in.

It's not just me.. it's all guys that aren't asian and don't bible thump.

I see, my bad. But nonetheless, if I had to guess, they simply don't trust that you'll be a good influence for their daughter or take good care of her. I won't argue whether or not they have the right to act as the date filter, but it's something you need to think about. It'll probably be harder for you to gain their trust, but if you believe she's worth the work of gaining the trust of her parents, then you'll figure something out.

btw... you shouldn't make HER pay you back. I'm lazy and so I would suggest taking the loss. If not, then ask her to talk to her parents to give the phone back so she can give it back to you. But don't make her pay you unless you're really through with her.

Agreed. I don't think the phone is worth it, unless they give it back to her and tell her to get rid of it.

I really would like that money back, i'm a 1st year university student.. it's an 'cheap' life,

 

[erikiksaz]

You'd ask your own girlfriend to pay you back for the phone you gave her? Shoot, if i were the girlfriend and you confronted me with this, i'd break up with you THAT INSTANT. She never asked you to buy her a phone, let alone pay for the service.

 

[mwtgg]

Originally posted by: RyanSengara

Originally posted by: TuxDave

Originally posted by: RyanSengara

Originally posted by: TuxDave
Call it a hunch, but perhaps the parents really don't like you hanging around with her. Especially since you're bragging about having pictures of her doing.......

I sympathize with the parents. They don't want you seeing her and they just beat your little gimmick to get around them.

Read one of my above posts. I don't have pictures of her DOING anything. I've got pictures of her in the hottub, other than that nada.

Edit: Summarily, they don't like any guys except for guys in their church. Her parents have been so stringent/overbearing on her that she's rebelled against absolutely everything her parents believe in.

It's not just me.. it's all guys that aren't asian and don't bible thump.

I see, my bad. But nonetheless, if I had to guess, they simply don't trust that you'll be a good influence for their daughter or take good care of her. I won't argue whether or not they have the right to act as the date filter, but it's something you need to think about. It'll probably be harder for you to gain their trust, but if you believe she's worth the work of gaining the trust of her parents, then you'll figure something out.

btw... you shouldn't make HER pay you back. I'm lazy and so I would suggest taking the loss. If not, then ask her to talk to her parents to give the phone back so she can give it back to you. But don't make her pay you unless you're really through with her.

Agreed. I don't think the phone is worth it, unless they give it back to her and tell her to get rid of it.

I really would like that money back, i'm a 1st year university student.. it's an 'cheap' life,

Isn't that a shame? Maybe you should have thought about it before you undermined your girlfriend's parents' authority?

 

[PowerMac4Ever]

Originally posted by: RyanSengara

Originally posted by: GT578
You're a cheap boyfriend. WHo the hell would want that back when the relationship is over?? Just cancel the service and be done with it.

I'm a cheap boyfriend?

$200 custom teddy bear for birthday
$400 in clothing for no reason when I was in New York
$100 Ring

The list goes on

You and WayneTek should compare notes, see what you're doing wrong... poser!

 

[whattaguy]

Sounds like you care more about the phone. If that's the case, get it back. You took a big risk getting her the phone with the knowledge of what her parents thought. You lost. Lesson learned. Move on.

 

[Bacardi151]

from what i've seen and heard, the relationship is by far not worth it!

this is your opportunity to get out, and you better jump it before they finally will acknowledge you as her bf. but believe me, that's not the end of it. they'll turn you into a jesus freak and soon enough you will be in that same church they attend next to your gf and exchanging vows....so run forrest run!

 

[Kelvrick]

hahha. Sorry, you're an ass and her parents are doing her a favor.

Wow, out of the year and a half, you've spent 600 bucks huh. Its the cost of being in a relationship idiot. And wow, a $100 ring? Canadian? What kind of sh1t did you give her that cost $100. Thats not the point, maybe its all you could afford, but no, thats not the situation. You got that $200 teddy bear and the clothes, but the best ring you could afford was $100. Why even list that? Thats like a dinner sometimes between me and my gf.

You knew what the parents were like, and you even made a thread about what kind of cheap phone to get in case you lost it. Well, guess what? You lost it.

 

[NutBucket]

Originally posted by: RyanSengara

Originally posted by: rahvin

Originally posted by: RyanSengara

Originally posted by: dabuddha
Take pictures of her "paying" you back and mail them to her parents.

I've already got pictures

Admitting on the internet that you are in possesion of child pornography is probably not the smartest thing to do. You also have implied in the same thread that you have likely commited statutory rape (depending on what state you live in).

You aren't the smartest cookie in the box are you?

I was younger than 18 at the time, it wasn't statuatory, the laws are different in Canada. I did ALOT of research into this, because I was in alot of trouble.

And I don't have any nekkid pics of her.. just rather revealing pictures.. people on this board have seen them. They're of her in her bikini and stuff.

Time to repost them

 

[CraigRT]

ask the parents why they want to ruin her life so much.

i swear i never had any such hassles in my life like that, and i won't ever treat my kids like that... i hate when parents are THAT controlling.... brutal.

 

[RbSX]

Originally posted by: CraigRT
ask the parents why they want to ruin her life so much.

i swear i never had any such hassles in my life like that, and i won't ever treat my kids like that... i hate when parents are THAT controlling.... brutal.

*puts on flamesuit*

Lemme see here..

Traditional asian
Protestant religious zealots
Serious inferiority complex
=
Disaster

I've already put her type on my DO NOT DATE list, not because of her, but because of the problems that family can cause.

 

[TranceNation]

Originally posted by: RyanSengara
Hey guys

About 3 weeks ago I bought my girlfriend a cellphone, and paid for the service.

Some of you might ask why I was doing this, suffice to say her parents are cruel heartless people, and they barely ever let her talk on the phone or go on MSN.. or go out for that matter.

Anyways last night (2 weeks after I managed to get her the phone).. her parents find it, confiscate the phone.. and it's gone and I'll never get it back..

This phone set me back $100 bucks + service fees this month, and she's already lost it.

Should I get verbalize my anger? Make her pay me back.

I'm already pretty pissed off abotu this.

I'm not sure how much $100 is to you but that's really no big deal. Are you in college/school? Do you have a job? I would say $100 is nothing if you have a job and asking for her to you back will detriment your relationship with her, not to mention making you look like a 'cheap' person

 

[TuxDave]

Originally posted by: NutBucket

Originally posted by: RyanSengara
I was younger than 18 at the time, it wasn't statuatory, the laws are different in Canada. I did ALOT of research into this, because I was in alot of trouble.

And I don't have any nekkid pics of her.. just rather revealing pictures.. people on this board have seen them. They're of her in her bikini and stuff.

Time to repost them

:thumbsup:

 

[Nitemare]

Originally posted by: RyanSengara

Originally posted by: dabuddha
Take pictures of her "paying" you back and mail them to her parents.

I've already got pictures

Want some more?


Bada bing *cymbal crash*

 

[tk149]

If you gave your gf the phone, the common law rule (at least in the U.S.) is "A gift given is gone." That means you have no right to get it (or monetary compensation) back.

If you loaned her the phone, and specifically made it clear to her that it was a loan, then you have a right to get it back. Now you just have to convince her parents that you, Mr. Smartypants, had more of a right to decide what is best for their daughter than they did, and oh, please, can I have that phone back?

Or you can ask your soon-to-be-ex-gf for the money for the phone, in which case she owes you the market value of a used phone.

Sorry, bud, but you were a tool, you got used, and you've just been abused. Welcome to the wonderful world of dating.

 

[Aquaman]

Eh........ don't you go to school in at Queens or York or somthing like that ? That's one hellava phone bill dude :Q

Cheers,
Aquaman

 

[Ender]

You live in West Vancouver and you're complaining about a $100 cell phone? Rofl... the asian kids at my school toss around $300 digital camera phones like nothing and my friend ended up breaking his. Got another one the next week.