This will be a long post, and it deals with a touchy subject. Please do not flame, and no trolling please! Civilized discussion only!
Ok it all started with this thread. Someone made a comment asking whether the person who was dying is "saved" or not. Then I made another comment at the bottom, basically saying that I dont agree about the "saved" concept of christianity. I believe that all religions are equal, and saying that if a person does not convert to christian, then he is not saved is just wrong. By the way I am christian as well.
Sooo a couple of days later someone PMed me the following message (lets call him JohnDoe, since I dont want to reveal his identity, it is up to him if he wants to reveal his identity):
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by: z0mb13
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by: Atomicus
My sympathy goes out to you and those around your family. In all seriousness, is she saved?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm sorry, but asking whether she is saved or not is just pure FLAMEBAIT!
I am christian, but I have half a mind NOT to say this to people
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
You would rather people feel secure and happy in complacency, than people feel uncomfortable and challenged by being exposed to Christ?
Misplaced priorities, man. Much of what Paul did in his ministry would've been "flamebait", and almost all of Jesus' ministry on earth was "flamebait". I'm not saying that we should seek to start arguments concerning God, because many times that leads nowhere and simply alienates the ones whom we wish to bring to Christ, but there are times when pressing the issue, even though it may cause discomfort.
Then I replied back with this:
I am sorry but maybe its just because I am too liberal?
IMO it is wrong to force your religion to other people.
I believe all religion are good, one is not better or worse than the other.
Saying that a person is not "saved" if he/she doesnt convert to christinaity is the same as saying that christinaity is superior to any religion on earth. Or even worse, saying that the religion that the person believes in is WORSE than christianity.
I was brought up (and still believe) that all religion are good. I was exposed to multiple religions when I was a kid, and I respect all of them.
I dont condone spreading christianity throughout the world, because I know that christianity is Good, and it has good ideas and merit. However bashing other religions is a no no.
Imagine if other religion say that you will never go to heaven since you dont follow their religion. I dont have to go too far for an example: a certain denomination of christianity claims that catholics will go to hell unless they convert to their denomination
Then he replied back with this:
In that case, then, your religion is false. You can't call it Christianity, because it isn't.
I understand that this may seem "intolerant" or "hateful" to you, but to reject outright what Christ Himself said is glaringly, for lack of better word, "unchristian".
John 14:6 - No one comes to the Father except through Me..
Christ is the only way to Heaven, and all other paths lead to Hell. Unbalanced, you say? The Bible agrees. There is only one way to Heaven (Christ) whereas there are many ways to destruction.
As much as I respect other people, I will not tolerate someone whom may very well be a brother of mine in Christ (because as far as I know, you have accepted Christ as your savior) being led astray by Satan's influence.
Call me a fundamentalist, or a zealot, it will not change what God has said.
Then I replied with this:
oh and another one, what is your view on racism? Is it ok to be racist to another race?
I am willing to bet that you are against racism (well if you agree with racism then my following argument will be shot).
What is the difference between believing that your race is superiror than someone else's, from believeing that your religion is better than other people's religion? Your only saving grace is because you have God for reasoning.
Then he replied:
The spiritual is on a completely different plane than physical. This world is only temporary, and thus what we are given on it should not matter nearly as much as our souls, which are eternal, created by God. To scale it down, it would be sort of like judging someone by their character. Past the skin color, past the mental capacity, each human created by God has a soul meant to glorify God, through worship and also through doing what God enabled us to do (i.e. using talents given to us, or other such blessings, such as they are called).
You say "better". "Better" is a term for relativism. That is to say, it is a sliding scale, i.e. milk is good, but OJ is better. That's not the issue in Christianity. The issue is that Christianity is true, and all other religions are false.
So whats your take in this??
Ok it all started with this thread. Someone made a comment asking whether the person who was dying is "saved" or not. Then I made another comment at the bottom, basically saying that I dont agree about the "saved" concept of christianity. I believe that all religions are equal, and saying that if a person does not convert to christian, then he is not saved is just wrong. By the way I am christian as well.
Sooo a couple of days later someone PMed me the following message (lets call him JohnDoe, since I dont want to reveal his identity, it is up to him if he wants to reveal his identity):
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by: z0mb13
quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by: Atomicus
My sympathy goes out to you and those around your family. In all seriousness, is she saved?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I'm sorry, but asking whether she is saved or not is just pure FLAMEBAIT!
I am christian, but I have half a mind NOT to say this to people
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
You would rather people feel secure and happy in complacency, than people feel uncomfortable and challenged by being exposed to Christ?
Misplaced priorities, man. Much of what Paul did in his ministry would've been "flamebait", and almost all of Jesus' ministry on earth was "flamebait". I'm not saying that we should seek to start arguments concerning God, because many times that leads nowhere and simply alienates the ones whom we wish to bring to Christ, but there are times when pressing the issue, even though it may cause discomfort.
Then I replied back with this:
I am sorry but maybe its just because I am too liberal?
IMO it is wrong to force your religion to other people.
I believe all religion are good, one is not better or worse than the other.
Saying that a person is not "saved" if he/she doesnt convert to christinaity is the same as saying that christinaity is superior to any religion on earth. Or even worse, saying that the religion that the person believes in is WORSE than christianity.
I was brought up (and still believe) that all religion are good. I was exposed to multiple religions when I was a kid, and I respect all of them.
I dont condone spreading christianity throughout the world, because I know that christianity is Good, and it has good ideas and merit. However bashing other religions is a no no.
Imagine if other religion say that you will never go to heaven since you dont follow their religion. I dont have to go too far for an example: a certain denomination of christianity claims that catholics will go to hell unless they convert to their denomination
Then he replied back with this:
In that case, then, your religion is false. You can't call it Christianity, because it isn't.
I understand that this may seem "intolerant" or "hateful" to you, but to reject outright what Christ Himself said is glaringly, for lack of better word, "unchristian".
John 14:6 - No one comes to the Father except through Me..
Christ is the only way to Heaven, and all other paths lead to Hell. Unbalanced, you say? The Bible agrees. There is only one way to Heaven (Christ) whereas there are many ways to destruction.
As much as I respect other people, I will not tolerate someone whom may very well be a brother of mine in Christ (because as far as I know, you have accepted Christ as your savior) being led astray by Satan's influence.
Call me a fundamentalist, or a zealot, it will not change what God has said.
Then I replied with this:
oh and another one, what is your view on racism? Is it ok to be racist to another race?
I am willing to bet that you are against racism (well if you agree with racism then my following argument will be shot).
What is the difference between believing that your race is superiror than someone else's, from believeing that your religion is better than other people's religion? Your only saving grace is because you have God for reasoning.
Then he replied:
The spiritual is on a completely different plane than physical. This world is only temporary, and thus what we are given on it should not matter nearly as much as our souls, which are eternal, created by God. To scale it down, it would be sort of like judging someone by their character. Past the skin color, past the mental capacity, each human created by God has a soul meant to glorify God, through worship and also through doing what God enabled us to do (i.e. using talents given to us, or other such blessings, such as they are called).
You say "better". "Better" is a term for relativism. That is to say, it is a sliding scale, i.e. milk is good, but OJ is better. That's not the issue in Christianity. The issue is that Christianity is true, and all other religions are false.
So whats your take in this??